Should the Vatican back history’s biggest IPO?

On Oct. 26, Anthropic AI formally submitted the documents required to register its shares for a possible public stock market listing. The proposed Initial Public Offering (IPO) is already being discussed as a potential contender for the largest stock-market float in history.

Early estimates suggest Anthropic’s valuation could reach between $1.5 and $2 trillion. If those predictions prove correct, the prospect of public investment in one of the world’s most consequential AI companies may be closer than many expected.

A moment of reckoning

This world-transforming event demands something of us as Christians: an invitation to consider the value of human life and the purpose of human existence.

Anthropic has acknowledged that advanced AI could pose catastrophic or existential risks to humanity. How, then, should Catholic Social Teaching respond to what some regard as one of the greatest existential challenges of our time?

Searching our tradition

As Christians, we need to search the treasures of our tradition for prophetic truth that speaks into the zeitgeist.

In his writings on lay spirituality such as Christifideles Laici 17, Pope John Paul II stressed that following Christ requires direct involvement in public life, politics, and social justice.

“The vocation of the lay faithful to holiness implies that life according to the Spirit expresses itself in a particular way in their involvement in temporal affairs and in their participation in earthly activities.” (CL17)

The problem is not that humanity creates intelligent technology. Human creativity and reason can themselves be gifts from God. Rather, the danger lies in the temptation to determine good and evil on human terms, apart from God.

As Genesis suggests, the desire to possess knowledge can become entangled with the desire to assume God’s authority. The question is not simply what AI can teach humanity, but whether humanity possesses the wisdom to govern what it creates.

When AI amplifies vice

Consider the events of July 8, 2025, when the AI chatbot Grok generated antisemitic posts, conspiracy theories and praise of Hitler. The incident demonstrated how AI systems can reproduce and amplify human vice, raising urgent questions about the responsibilities of those who develop, deploy and profit from them.

Perhaps Christians should view sin itself as an existential threat because it degrades the image of God in ourselves and in our fellow human beings.

A pantheon of AI

In a sense, humanity is creating a pantheon of competing AI gods, each with its own following. The world increasingly speaks of these systems as though they possess a power and authority beyond our own.

Could advanced AI become a modern object of misplaced faith?

In adapted words drawn from Psalm 97: “For you, O Anthropic, are most high above all the earth; you are exalted far beyond all gods.”

The psalm proclaims God’s sovereignty over creation. Applied to AI, it forces an uncomfortable question: should humanity risk elevating a human creation to a position of authority that, in the Christian tradition, belongs to God alone?

The largest stock-market float in history may generate immense wealth. Before investing in AI’s promise, we might first ask what, precisely, we are being asked to worship.

  • James Gordon Reid Haveloch Jones is an educational consultant, public theologian, and author of an Amazon Top 50 Study Skills bestseller. He is an Honorary Associate Fellow of St George’s House, Windsor Castle, and a trustee of the Heythrop Association at the University of London. He completed post-graduate studies at the University of Oxford Faculty of Theology. He is a Contracted Contributing Writer for the Catholic Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales (“God Who Speaks”) and a guest writer for: The Tablet, Church Times, National Catholic Reporter and Premier Christianity. Website: www.jamesgordonreid.co.uk

Get Flashes of Insight

We respect your email privacy

Search

Focal Points

AI Baptism Church History Church Reform Clericalism Communications & Media Compassion Culture Culture & Faith Digital Age Eucharist Exclusion Faith Faith Dialogue Gender Equality Hope Human Dignity Inclusion Justice Lay Leadership Leadership LGBTQ+ Liturgy Ministry Mission Peace Pope Francis Pope Leo XIV Poverty Prayer Priesthood Reconciliation Scripture Social Justice Synodality Theology Tradition Vatican Vatican II War Women Women's Ordination Women Deacons Women in Ministry Youth

Donate

All services bringing Flashes of Insight are donated.

Significant costs, such as those associated with site hosting, site design, and email delivery, mount up.

Flashes of Insight will shortly look for donations.